The Tenets of Tactical Ventilation: Part 1
1. Informed
On the fire-ground, information comes at a premium. Because every situation we face is inherently unique, intelligence gathering is always a top priority. From the moment an alarm is received, we are inundated with information – varying in degree of detail and accuracy. That information must be immediately processed, utilizing our knowledge base and intuition, and translated into an appropriate action plan (also known as ‘Recognition-Primed Decision Making’ or RPD). In the absence of a one-size-fits-all approach, the conditions will always dictate our actions. With so much at stake, it is incumbent upon us to, not only collect as much information as possible (without delaying action), but to disseminate that which is pertinent to the other members operating on scene and en route. Given the infinite number of potential variables, and the uncertainty of a rapidly changing, hostile environment, we are faced with the daunting challenge of ‘attempting to make perfect decisions with imperfect information.’
To minimize that differential, we must engage our senses and maintain a heightened state of (situational) awareness. By always being acutely cognizant of our surroundings, we can identify critical pieces of information, as they present themselves, which will guide us to effective decision-making. Upon arrival, this (physical) process begins by ‘sizing-up’ the incident. We must keenly observe the building as we approach; if we pull past or to the far corner of the building, we are granted a visual of three sides. Upon doing so, the officer of the first-due company should provide a ‘brief initial report (BIR).’ A model which is commonly utilized for such instances is the ‘CAN’ report: condition; actions; and needs. Following this transmission, a rapid survey of the exterior (and interior) should be made whenever feasible. Often referred to as the ‘360,’ it is more than simply ‘taking a lap’ to check the proverbial box, it provides us with a more complete picture of the incident. In regards to ventilation, particular attention must be placed upon building construction (layout, existing openings, and egress points), presentation of the smoke and fire, as well as the wind condition (direction and speed). We must remember that size-up is not a single act, it is a continuous process that must be strictly employed throughout the duration of the incident.
Not all of the information we obtain on the fire-ground is acquired first-hand. In fact, a great deal is received through radio transmissions (and word-of-mouth). By always keeping an ear to the radio, we can ascertain the whereabouts of other crews operating within the structure, their assigned tasks, their progress, as well as the conditions being encountered. Lt. Rob Brown, FDNY (2016) states, ‘One of the best ways to do this is to listen to all radio transmissions on the fire-ground to paint a mental picture, gauge the flow of the operation and be able to anticipate potential problems in other areas that may affect the objective.’ Amidst the fast-paced, high stress, and hostile environment that is the fire-ground, succumbing to the ‘fog of war’ can happen suddenly and often without our realization. When we allow our emotional response to elevate uncontrollably, we can become so overly task-oriented that we lose sight of what is going on around us; due to the onset of ‘tunnel-vision’ and ‘auditory exclusion.’ We must practice arousal control to maintain our composure, no matter what the circumstances.
Those engaging in ventilation activities, especially, must possess a much broader focus; as their actions can single-handedly and swiftly impact the course of an incident – potentially with severe implications. We must possess enough information to be sure that the ventilation plan has a defined objective that will facilitate a specific firefighting operation and the achievement of the mission – preserving life and property. Brown (2016) asserts that ‘Smart, aggressive firefighters never lose sight of where they fit into the operation (accountability) and how quickly their objective can change by monitoring their situation awareness…’ Possessing (and sharing) vital information is often the determining factor in the success of any operation. The need for vigilant situational awareness, coupled with accurate and concise communication then, becomes paramount. Those behaviors are just two of the fundamental components necessary for exercising fire ground discipline and the very basis for the concept of tactical ventilation.
2. Deliberate
The very basis for the act of ventilation is to improve tenability and facilitate firefighting operations. Being a supportive function, ventilation must be executed purposefully, with the resultant effect serving as an expedient towards achieving a specific objective. Historically, ventilation has been employed as a means to address the two foremost incident priorities of life safety and fire extinguishment; precipitating the common expression ‘vent for life and vent for fire.’ To further assert the tactical nature of its application, however, that old adage has been more aptly rephrased to as ‘vent for search’ and ‘vent for extinguishment.’ This seemingly trivial, semantical alteration serves as a blatant, yet necessary reminder that ventilation is task-oriented; requiring sound judgement to ensure that any actions taken are calculated and aid in the success of a particular operation. Given the continual changes (detriments) to the fire environment, the need for such prudence has never been more crucial.
The effect of ventilation has been commonly misinterpreted, prompting its propensity for malpractice. This deficiency has tragically resulted in numerous close calls and line of duty deaths. Operational competency is more than merely possessing the physical ability or technical proficiency necessary to execute a given tactic (the ‘how’), it is equally dependent on cognitive aptitude (the ‘where, when and why’). As Tom Brennan (2007) once wrote, ‘It is not simply a cut-and-bust operation. We are professional and select primary and secondary channels to improve conditions and positively impact the fire behavior based on an ongoing size-up.’ To be truly effective, we must marry knowledge, obtained through research and education (the ‘science’), with skill, developed through training and experience (the ‘art’). Thankfully, due to the extensive work of both UL and NIST, we now have substantial empirical data detailing the dynamics of fire and the impact of firefighting operations, most notably, ventilation. With this information, we can develop the comprehensive understanding necessary to close those gaps; creating firefighters who are not only aggressive, but ’smart aggressive’ (Brown, 2016).
Even with the best intentions, ventilation can have negative implications if certain variables are not accounted for and the subsequent precautions are not taken. The fact is often lost that ventilation, by its very design, increases air flow. If ventilation is not appropriately managed, controlling the intake of air to the fire area until extinguishment efforts are (effectively) underway, the fire will intensify. Creating an uncontrolled, low-pressure opening will result in greater air exchange and draw the fire to the new source of air supply (the path of least resistance); deteriorating conditions, rather than improving them, in the process. As William Clark (1991) stated, ‘Constantly consider that ventilation will cause the fire to grow rapidly and will increase the temperature in the fire compartment. Even ventilation above the fire will accelerate the burning rate by allowing fresh air to replace the oxygen deficient atmosphere that was slowing combustion.’ To prevent such an occurrence, the decision to ventilate must be predicated on the following: the conditions present (building construction and layout, fire location and extent, wind speed and direction); life hazard; progress of the interior crews; and the desired effect. Only when these factors are properly evaluated, can the appropriate actions be taken.
Venting for search has traditionally been a rather loosely applied tactic. There were rarely any standardized protocols established for its use, with the exception of Vent-Enter-Search (VES). The only real guideline set forth was simply that if the (interior) search effort was inhibited, due to high heat and/or low visibility, windows could be taken to improve conditions; with the intent of enhancing orientation and tenability. Little to no insight or consideration, however, was commonly given as to its potential impact on the fire and the necessary precautions that must be taken to ensure its effectiveness. Without this critical understanding, the ‘vent-as-you-go’ concept was often misguided and subsequently, improperly executed. As Vincent Dunn (2007) warned ‘…if venting is carried out before the hose team is ready, the fire may spread or firefighters inside a superheated room conducting a search may be burned by a flashover.’ Venting for search, when conducted appropriately (communicating intentions, coordinating efforts and controlling the door), is highly effective and can reap the ultimate reward – saving a life. Executing this tactic in an area that potentially cannot be isolated, prior to the fire being in check, however, comes with tremendous risk and should be reserved for situations where actionable intelligence of a life hazard is received – potential benefits outweighing the consequences. Members engaging in these operations are fighting the clock and must enlist the highest degree of situational awareness and operational proficiency to limit their exposure (and that of the victim) to the increasingly unstable environment.
Venting for extinguishment requires an equal degree of diligence, as it carries the same inherent risks if not applied correctly. The use of this tactic is intended to provide an outlet for the (by) products of combustion and steam generated by the stream of the hose line; relieving conditions and aiding in the advance of the engine company. Another old saying that is dangerously misleading, taken merely at face-value (and without the essential background knowledge), is ‘vent early, vent often.’ Successfully venting for extinguishment is contingent upon the location, timing and size of the opening created and the ability to effectively control the horizontal openings (doors and windows) within the area of involvement until a charged hose line is at least in position. Clark (1991) asserted that ‘Ventilation should begin, ordinarily, as soon as water is up to the nozzle, not before. The procedure will allow more air to get to the fire, which will accelerate the burning, and a charged hose line must therefore be ready to be moved into action as soon as ventilation begins.’ When effective extinguishment efforts are initiated, more energy will be absorbed by the water than generated by the fire and the subsequent cooling of the fuel packages will inhibit the combustion process. Upon which, the inlet of fresh air and exhaust of the residual heat and smoke will substantially increase visibility and decrease temperatures – enhancing tenability.
As we conduct ourselves on the fire-ground, we must not forget that every decision we make will, in some way, directly impact the course of the incident and the livelihood of all those involved. To paraphrase Newton’s Third Law of Motion, ‘for every action there is a reaction.’ Understanding the impact of our tactics is essential to the decision-making process and ensuring the appropriate interventions are selected and implemented to address the situation at hand. As a stark reminder, the FDNY has a sign posted at their training academy (known as ‘The Rock’) that reads, ‘Let no man’s ghost come back to say, ‘My training let me down.’’
Continue reading: The Tenets of Tactical Ventilation: Part 2
Content published from Euro Firefighter 2 and is written by Paul Grimwood, PhD, FIFireE

